ISSN: 2158-7051 ==================== INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES ==================== ISSUE NO. 8 ( 2019/2 ) |
PUTIN V. THE PEOPLE, THE PERILOUS POLITICS OF A DIVIDED RUSSIA, By Ayse Dietrich*, Published by: Yale
University Press, New Haven and London. Written by Samuel A.
Greene and Graeme B. Robertson, Year of Publishing: 2019. Subject Area:
Russian History, Russian Politics, Book Type: Political History. Total
Number of Pages: 287. ISBN: 9780300238396, $30 (Hardcover).
For centuries Russia had been ruled by authoritarian
tsars, and Vladimir Putin’s authoritarian tendencies grew out the previous periods
of the Russian Empire and the Soviet Union. Putin did not create
authoritarianism, but he inherited it and is a product of it. He justifies his
authoritarian style of leadership to garner popular support for his policies
which he claims strengthen the nation, protect Russia from both external and
internal threats, and benefit ordinary citizens.
Often referred to as a modern-day tsar, Putin’s
popularity is based on an image of leadership that can be traced back to the
Soviet era and beyond into the time of the tsars. This image is that of an
effective leader prepared to defend the honor and position of a nation that is
a self-reliant world power. Putin has revived the policy of attaining security
through the overt
use of Russian power, an attitude that would have been familiar to the tsars.
This book is about what ordinary Russians
think about Putin. What has made Putin so popular? Who are his supporters? And
why do they support him? It is also about struggle and resistance, the rise of
authoritarianism and its opponents. The authors dedicate a chapter to his
biography at the beginning of the book, and in the following chapters discuss his
strategies, his policies in handling tragic events and turning them into his advantage,
the inside of his mantra “Don’t excite the people”, and how he has used existing
but dormant social events, wedge issues, against the opposition to the
advantage of the regime. In addition, the writers examine the mix of people and
politics in the formation and maintenance of a regime centered on a single
charismatic, authoritarian figure.
Greene and Robertson in their book show us how
Putin rose “from lowly KGB colonel to an extraordinary position in the politics
of the country”, and explore the role of Russian society in building Putin’s
power, what authors call “the co-construction of Russian power”, and examine Russian
citizens’ unconditional support for him. The authors’ approach to understanding
the basis and application of Putin’s power is to investigate the actual
relationship between the authoritarian regime and ordinary citizens, not only
from the perspective of those at the top, but also that of those on the bottom.
By conducting interviews and surveys the
authors sought to determine the reasons for Putin’s popularity and the methods
he used to maintain popular support, such as control of the media and
dominating it; efforts to whip up “collective euphoria” over current events in
the region and then gauging popular reaction; creating strategies to gain and
keep the advantage over political rivals. However, the authors assert that the
success of all these methods is contingent on popular response, what the authors term “co-construction”. Loyalty to Putin becomes
equivalent to loyalty to the community, and many Russians will claim that Putin’s
power is not simply his ability to impose his will on Russian society, but is
actually the result of numerous private citizens acting as voluntary enforcers
of his will across society. Examples of this can take many forms, such as “the
boss who insists his employees vote; the school teacher who inculcates
uncritical acceptance of official stories of Putin’s heroism” etc.
However, the authors argue that basing his
power so heavily on the support of ordinary Russian citizens has left Putin
vulnerable should popular attitudes change. If the government or media become
less effective in shaping public opinion, or public perceptions of society or
the economy shift, or if Russian social institutions such as churches and
schools begin to adopt a more critical stance toward Putin and his government,
Putin’s ability to maintain his hold on power becomes more uncertain.
The authors conclude by tracing Putin’s
metamorphosis from a tool of the oligarchs intended to protect their interests,
to becoming the “father of the nation”. They describe the ways in which he was
able to use incessant media coverage and impose his views across all segments
of Russian society in the course of achieving his current status. The writers
also argue that Putin’s vast network of popular support makes him difficult to
replace, since neither his charism nor the support that it has garnered can be
easily transferred to a new leader.
This work is well researched and well written
and provides not only information on Putin’s life and career, but extremely
informative about how he attained his current popularity and status in Russia,
and how he maintains it. The book is highly recommended for anyone interested
in not only Vladimir Putin and contemporary Russian politics and society, but
also for anyone interested in the means by which charismatic authoritarian
politicians rise to power, silence or eliminate their opponents, and maintain
their hold on power.
*Ayse Dietrich - Professor, Part-time, at Middle East Technical University, Department of History, and Eurasian Studies. Editor and the founder of the International Journal of Russian Studies e-mail: editor@ijors.net, dayse@metu.edu.tr, dietrichayse@yahoo.com
© 2010, IJORS - INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES