ISSN: 2158-7051 ==================== INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES ==================== ISSUE NO. 11 ( 2022/2 ) |
THE STRONG MAN VLADIMIR PUTIN AND THE STRUGGLE FOR RUSSIA, By Ayse Dietrich*, Published by I. B. Tauris,
Bloomsbury Publishing, Written by Angus Roxburgh, Year of Publishing: 2021.
Subject Area: Putin, Russian Politics. Book Type: Russian Political History.
Total Number of Pages: 428. ISBN: 9780755639250, paperback, $17.95.
The
former BBC Moscow correspondent Angus Roxburgh who became a Kremlin media consultant wrote this book when he was a chief consultant for a four-part BBC television documentary titled ‘Putin, Russia &
the West’. His top-level interviews in Russia, the US, Britain, France, Germany, Ukraine and Georgia are also
used to fill out the details of the events covered in his book. The author has used his personal experiences as an advisor
for three years to President Putin’s press
secretary, Dmitry Peskov. Roxburgh presents Russia’s struggle
for their future under Putin after the collapse of communism, her isolation for
decades from the Western world, the failure of the West to understand her fears
and aspirations during this new transformation with respect and her ambitions
as a country that wants to be part of the world.
The book is comprised of an introduction and sixteen
chapters. Chapter one starts with the announcement of Yeltsin’s
resignation and his designation of Putin as his successor, and Putin’ s inheritance from Yeltsin of a Russia that was economically and
militarily weak, run by
thugs, and patronized by the West. The author gives us very clear picture of a
country dealing with mafia-style gangs, killings, and soaring inflation. He
describes how impoverished Russians were selling their belongings on the
pavements; Moscow had become a huge flea-market, railway stations were filled
with beggars and homeless people, industries had collapse, and enterprises conducted
business with each other by barter etc. The abrupt transition from communism
and the loss of their own country shocked the Russians: the
Soviet Union, a land of 250 million people in 15 national republics, had fallen
apart. Twenty-five million Russians suddenly found themselves foreigners in
their countries. The author states that the Kremlin’s Western advisors did not
know how to handle this dislocated society; and Western countries did not
notice the chaos since they were obsessed with the idea of building capitalism,
regardless of its immediate impact. The West assumed that Russians would simply
know how to use their liberty; transformation would be quick and chaos was
something totally natural in a transitional period that would soon be replaced
by normal life.
In
Chapter two, the author talks about Putin’s conciliatory gestures to the
West, his approval of the closure of two Soviet-era military facilities abroad
– a naval base at Cam Ranh Bay in Vietnam and a
listening post at Lourdes in Cuba; his cooperation with America in dealing with
the Taliban issue etc.
Chapter
three
is about his battle for economic reform. The author states that although
Yeltsin carried out major projects such as mass privatization and the
liberalization of prices that transformed the economy, the country did not have
sustainable economic growth, inflation was high and the new private sector
worked inefficiently. He emphasizes that Putin impressed the West with his
economic reforms that stimulated the economy, and established the free market with
the help of a new team of Western-oriented reformers to draw up a program. The
author provides detailed information on briefings and sessions, projects and plans.
He states that the Gref plan that was
approved in 2000 during Putin’s first term introduced tax and progressive
pension reforms, adopted a new land code that made it possible to buy and sell
commercial and residential land, eliminated barriers to opening and running a
business, introduced civil service reforms, reduced personal income tax, and sped
up negotiations on Russia’s joining the WTO. This led to a sharp acceleration
of economic growth, an influx of foreign investment and the strengthening of
the ruble.
In
Chapter four, Roxburgh talks about the crackdown on the free media. He
states that Western traditions of balance and independence had not taken root
under Putin, and one of Putin’s earliest decisions was to start creating what
he called the ‘vertical of power’, the gathering-in of all political power to
the center, and effectively into his own hands.
In
Chapter five, the author talks about Putin’s concerns on whether Russia
would be excluded from the top table, his belief that Russia was not being
treated as a superpower any more, his craving for respect from the West and his
Western-style approach to alliances by creating a new NATO–Russia Council to include
the Russians in the Western alliance. This chapter also provides information on
tensions over the Iraq issue and the growing confrontation with America on the
cancellation of America’s missile defense plans etc.
Chapter
six concerns
the start of what became known as the Rose Revolution that ousted Eduard
Shevardnadze, ended the Soviet era of leadership in the country (which Putin
saw it as a threat to Russia itself), brought Mikheil Saakashvili to power, democracy
to countries on Russia’s borders, and orientated Georgia towards the West.
Chapter
seven, gives
information on the Orange Revolution, a series of protests and political events
that took place in Ukraine (seen by Putin as the most important for Russia of
all the former Soviet republics since it was the last buffer between Russia and
the ever-expanding NATO) in November 2004, his efforts to sort things out, how
Ukraine became a battleground for influence, with the United States, Russia’s
open support for both opposing candidates, and Putin’s reactions and his
sanctions (the gas wars).
In
Chapter eight, the author talks about the aftermath of the Orange
Revolution in 2005, and how the West became powerless when Putin began to
curtail democracy, create Nashi (Youth Democratic Anti-Fascist Movement), crack down on
Non-Governmental Organizations and turn off gas supplies to Ukraine, murder of
the dissident journalist Anna Politkovskaya, URPO’s violence (Division of
Operations against Criminal Organizations) within the Federal Security Service,
growing tension between Russia and America over recent event in Georgia, America’s
threat to step in in case Russia does anything in Georgia.
Chapter
nine is
based on Roxburgh’s own experiences as the chief Russia consultant and working
for three years as an adviser to President Putin’s press secretary, Dmitry Peskov.
It talks about Putin’s negative image
created by his increasing authoritarianism, his stifling the opposition and
increasing control over NGOs, and the murders of Politkovskaya and other
journalists that resulted in calls from conservative quarters of the G8 to
expel Russia from the organization. The main task of Russia’s leadership was to
burnish that image with the help of a Western public-relations company, so an
American PR organization Ketchum and its Brussels-based partner, GPlus were employed by the Kremlin as a propaganda tool. The author mentions his work experience with Ketchum
and Gplus, the state-controlled Russia Today (RT) and
the Kremlin. He also discusses the invasion of Georgia and how it destroyed the
positive efforts made by Putin.
In
Chapter ten, the author talks about why Putin opposed the recognition of
Kosovo’s independence, which he believed would encourage a separatist movement
in the Caucasus, and would send a message to the Chechens, the Abkhazians and
South Ossetians that their demand to secede would not be ignored. He also discusses
the Russo-Georgian war, the approach of the West to it, and its consequences.
Chapter
eleven is
about the backlash to the Caucasian war, the gas conflict with Ukraine, Russia’s
relationship with the new US president Obama, Medvedev’s changing the agenda at
home, and his foreign policy objectives to reconcile with the West over Iran.
Chapter
twelve
examines the global crisis and its effects on Putin’s Russia in 2008 that
exposed the weakness of semi-reformed economy, the government’s effort to
prevent the collapse of the banking system, and corruption which was the
biggest obstacle to foreign investment, as well as the destroyer of the economy
and a politically explosive issue.
In
Chapter thirteen, the author discusses the question of whether there are
signs of a division in the ruling tandem of Prime Minister Vladimir Putin and
President Dmitry Medvedev and examines the similarities and differences between
the two leaders.
Chapter
fourteen
begins with Putin’s dramatic announcement of the scenario that had been created
by the two leader to alternate between the positions
of the presidency and prime minister. It talks about the 2012 election, the treatment
of the opposition, and the dictatorship of the law by Putin and legal nihilism
by Medvedev that became a tool of political repression. The chapter also
stresses the contradictory attitudes of Russia towards the West: the West is viewed by Putin Mark III as prosperous and
successful but at the same time evil because of their double standards and their
support and financing of the opposition. For him ‘Russia’s democracy means the
power of the Russian people with their own traditions of self-rule and not the
fulfilment of standards imposed on them from the outside’.
Chapter
fifteen
provides information on a confident Putin ready to offer Russian values as an
alternative to Western liberal democracy, and Russia itself as a bastion of
conservative, traditional values that occupies a superior place with its own
sphere of influence and legitimate security interests. The chapter also
examines the Putin’s Crimean adventure which put enormous strain on Russia’s
budget, his strict control over the media and internet, the GRU (military
intelligence agency)’s involvement in illegal activities, and Russia’s war in Syria.
In
Chapter sixteen, the author talks about Putin’s fear that he was not
allowed to run again in 2024, and his genuine worry that the oligarchy he has
created is becoming autonomous. He states that their growing concerns and
distrust drive them to consider scenarios for Russia’s future under Putin and
after he is gone. According to Roxburgh, Putin’s control over the oligarchs and
cronies is complicated; his system is “corrupt, larcenous and incestuous and
stable only so long as the lynchpin at its center remained in place”.
The
book is written by Roxburgh, an eyewitness to Russia’s
transition from communism to today’s Russia,
and it is valuable as a first-hand source for information about the
people and events of the Putin era. It is an excellent supplement to use in
conjunction with other, more official sources.
*Ayse Dietrich - Professor, Part-time, at Middle East Technical University, Department of History and Eurasian Studies. Editor and the founder of the International Journal of Russian Studies (IJORS) e-mail: editor@ijors.net, dayse@metu.edu.tr, dietrichayse@yahoo.com
© 2010, IJORS - INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES