ISSN: 2158-7051 ==================== INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES ==================== ISSUE NO. 11 ( 2022/2 ) |
ASSIGNMENT MOSCOW REPORTING ON RUSSIA FROM LENIN TO PUTIN, By Ayse Dietrich*,
Published by I. B. Tauris, Bloomsbury Publishing, Written
by James Rodgers, Year of
Publishing: 2020. Subject Area: Memoir, Book Type: Journalism. Total Number of
Pages: 237. ISBN: 978-0-7556-0115-8,
hardback, $27.00.
Assignment Moscow Reporting
on Russia from Lenin to Putin is a book written by a
former correspondent who spent his time in Russia and brought out the facts of
a closed society, in which the Kremlin controls the sources of information.
Newspapers, radio and television have been enlisted to serve the state, and paper
supplies were strictly guarded. Local journalists who knew the truth couldn’t publish
it, but foreign journalists did. Rodgers believed that British and
American reports on Russia had a disproportionate influence on the formation
of audiences’ views of the country.
The book is comprised of
an Introduction and ten chapters. In the Introduction, the author states that
his book is a reflection on his own work as a journalist. In the first
chapters, Rodgers includes newspaper reports from the time; correspondents’ memoirs,
and unpublished letters and memoranda exchanged between correspondents, editors
and others. In the later chapters, the author uses the same sources listed as
well as interviews with former Moscow correspondents.
Chapter
1 deals with the coverage of the Russian Revolution in 1917, and highlights the
great variation in how it was regarded by the reporters and their editors who
were eyewitnesses to, and chroniclers of, events that would shape the remainder
of the 20th century. In chapter 2 the author shows how many western
journalists found themselves taking sides in the internal fighting that follwed the revolution. Despite reporting the same events,
many of these correspondents interpreted them differently, and, as a result,
came to extremely divergent conclusions regarding them.
Chapters
3 through 5 cover the Stalin years, with chapter 3 examining the controversial
lack of western journalistic coverage of the extreme famine in Russia which
accompanied Stalin’s agricultural reforms. Chapter 4 is dedicated to the topic
of the coverage of the show trials of Stalin’s purported “enemies”. It
demonstrates that one of their primary purposes was to create a strong
impression both domestically, and internationally via western press coverage.
The following chapter, chapter 5, discusses the coverage of the Second World
War from Russia, a rare period of cooperation between the communists and the
capitalists to defeat their common enemy, Nazi Germany. In this chapter the author
points out the fact that the Russians almost always kept western journalists
away from the fighting may have negatively affected western reporting of the
Soviets’ role in defeating the Nazis. While many in the west underestimate the
Soviet contribution to the Allied victory in Europe, in Russia this victory is
regarded as being almost sacred.
Chapter
6 moves on to the post-war period when relations between Russia and the West
deteriorated rapidly. As relations soured, the increasing restrictions imposed
by the Soviets on western journalists during the Cold War resulted in a
reduction in the number of western journalists in Russia. Some news services
even questioned the value of maintaining journalists in a country that made
reporting so difficult. The next two chapters the tumultuous years of the
transition from communism to Russia under Putin through 2008. In addition to chronocling the coverage of the events of these years by
the western press, it also follows the collapse of the euphoria that the end of
communism had created.
Chapter
9 is dedicated to the reporting on the major events of Putin’s first two terms
through the Russian war in Georgia in 2008. The author discusses the techniques
of media manipulation first used during this conflict, and argues that more
sophisticated variants of them are currently in use. The final chapter, chapter
10, is a reflection on the experiences of Western journalists reporting from
Russia today, discussing which aspects or reporting on Russia are new and which
ones have been shared by journalists since the Russian Revolution.
In sum, Rodgers’s memoir is
based on newspaper reports from the time and interviews with former Moscow
reporters. The author has made a great
contribution to clarify a number of important aspects of Russian history, and
his work would be of interest to historians, readers interested
in understanding the practice of journalism and journalism students.
*Ayse Dietrich - Professor, Part-time, at Middle East Technical University, Department of History and Eurasian Studies. Editor and the founder of the International Journal of Russian Studies (IJORS) e-mail: editor@ijors.net, dayse@metu.edu.tr, dietrichayse@yahoo.com
© 2010, IJORS - INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES