ISSN: 2158-7051 ==================== INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES ==================== ISSUE NO. 11 ( 2022/1 ) |
WRITING RESISTANCE REVOLUTIONARY MEMOIRS OF SHLISSEL’BURG PRISON, 1881-1906, By Ayse Dietrich*, Published by UCLPress, Edited and Translated by Sarah
Young, Year of Publishing: 2021. Subject Area: Memoirs, Prison life, Russian
Revolutionaries. Book Type: Russian History. Total Number of Pages: 251. ISBN: 978-1787359925, paperback, $25.00.
This
book is about the memoirs of the members of one branch called People’s Will (Narodnaya volya) of the Populist Movement (Narodnik Movement) that conducted terrorist
activities, and were imprisoned in Shlissel’burg
Fortress between 1884 and 1905. Young is the editor and the translator of these
memoirs.
Who
were the Populists? After the
emancipation of the serfs in 1861 under Tsar Alexander II and the dissatisfaction with it, the Populist Movement, which was a spontaneous
and purely national socialist revolutionary movement, evolved among Russian
intellectuals. The Populists respected the peasant commune, and believed that
teaching the values of socialism would lead to the awakening of the masses and
the liberalization of the tsarist regime. The Populists had a firm belief in
the Russian peasants’ readiness for revolution, and believed that revolutionary
ideas would be easily propagated among them. The Revolutionaries ignored their
differences over theoretical details and were united by their belief in the
peasants’ readiness for revolution.
The movement could hardly be called a mass movement.
It was rather a collection of people who were determined to serve the people
and were convinced that behind them marched a million peasants. However, the
peasantry was not ready for action, and were still loyal to their “Father”, the
tsar. Therefore, the Populists began to turn their attention to the
discontented proletariat in the towns.
The Populists took their name from the Russian word narod (people). From the late 1860s, they developed
a movement called going to the people (khozhdenie
v narod). This group advocated that the peasantry
would be the source of social revolution. In the Populists’ movement
intellectuals, doctors, teachers and students dressed in peasant clothes
travelled to the countryside to spread their ideology and to encourage the
peasantry to rise at once, and to check their loyalty. But the peasants easily
identified the strangers and called the police. The Populists were arrested and
put on trial.
The
book is comprised of the memoirs of three prisoners who were convicted of
revolutionary activities and terrorism, and confined to the maximum
security prison at Shlissel’burg Fortress: the
memoirs of Liudmila Volkenshtein, the memoirs of Mikhail Ashenbrenner
and the memoirs of Vasilii Pankratov.
These memoirs were translated into English for the first time by Young.
The
book contains four chapter. The first chapter includes editor’s introduction in
which Young states that in 1884, 68 prisoners convicted of terrorism
and revolutionary activities were transferred to Shlissel´burg Fortress, and 18 of
these prisoners who served sentences averaging over 15 years, wrote about their
own and their fellow inmates’ experiences in prison, and illustrated the harsh
prison conditions. Young expresses the importance of these memoirs not only for
the Russian revolutionary mythology but also for the development of the
tradition of prison writing.
Young examines three texts written by Liudmila Volkenshtein
(1857–1906), Mikhail Ashenbrenner (1842–1926) and Vasilii Pankratov (1864–1925),
not translated into English. She states that these texts also reveal the
communal values, group identity, how the survivors resisted the harsh prison
authorities to improve living conditions and their
severe
mental and physical deterioration in isolation, from which over half of them
died.
In
the second chapter, Young examines the memoirs of the prisoner Liudmila Aleksandrovna Volkenshtein written on the way to Sakhalin and her
experiences in Shlissel’burg Fortress for 13 years. The
first edition was published in Great Britain, and the second edition appeared
in Berlin.
The author states that at first Volkenshtein received a death sentence, but later her
sentence was reduced to 15 years’ hard labor in Shlissel’burg
Fortress in 1884. In 1896, Volkenshtein was transferred
to Sakhalin Island, then to the Peter and Paul Fortress till March 1897, and
finally she was sent to Odessa.
During the Russo-Japanese War in 1905, Volkenshtein was involved in a number of protests and died in
the shooting on demonstrators on 10 (23) January 1906.
In the third chapter, Young examines the
writings of the prisoner Mikhail Iul’evich Ashenbrenner who met some members of the People’s Will in
the mid-1870s and joined the military. Because of their radical plans, Ashenbrenner and his friends were betrayed and arrested. Ashenbrenner was sent to the Peter and Paul Fortress and
sentenced to death, but later his sentence was reduced to life at hard labor,
and transferred to Shlissel’burg Fortress in 1884. After
spending 20 years in the prison, he was exiled to Smolensk in 1904, but he
continued his revolutionary activities by assisting the Socialist
Revolutionaries. He spent his final years in Moscow and died in 1926.
In
the fourth chapter, Young examines the writings of the prisoner, Vasilii Semenovich Pankratov who joined the People’s Will in 1883. He received
a death sentence, but it was commuted to 20 years’ hard labor, and he was transferred
to Shlissel’burg Fortress. Due to the coronation
amnesty of 1896, his sentence was reduced by one third, and in 1898, he was exiled
to Viliuisk. In 1903, he joined the Socialist
Revolutionary Party (SR), and in 1905, he escaped from exile to return to
Moscow. He joined the Moscow Uprising of 1905, and in 1907 he was sent back to Iakutsk for five years. In 1909, he played an active role
in the SR Party’s Central Committee, and returned to Petersburg in 1912. After
Lenin dissolved the Constituent Assembly and closed all the parties, he joined
the opponents. After the SRs ended their opposition to the Bolsheviks in 1919, Pankratov began to support Admiral Kolchak to continue fighting
against the Bolsheviks. The SR Party expelled him, and when the Civil War ended,
Pankratov returned to Petrograd and became a member
of the Society for Former Political Prisoners. He died in Leningrad in1925.
The memoirs of these inmates
presented in this book were active political members of the Populist Movement
who spent many years of their lives in Shlissel’burg
Fortress, and boldly and openly illustrated their experiences, sufferings, and their
struggle to survive prison life. Young
has made a great contribution to prison literature with her translations, and her work
would be of interest to academicians, researchers and students who are
interested in carceral life of political prisoners during the Soviet Union.
*Ayse Dietrich - Professor, Part-time, at Middle East Technical University, Department of History and Eurasian Studies. Editor and the founder of the International Journal of Russian Studies (IJORS) e-mail: editor@ijors.net, dayse@metu.edu.tr, dietrichayse@yahoo.com
© 2010, IJORS - INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES