ISSN: 2158-7051 ==================== INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES ==================== ISSUE NO. 8 ( 2019/2 ) |
RUSSIA’S CRONY CAPITALISM THE PATH FROM MARKET ECONOMY TO KLEPTOCRACY, By Ayse Dietrich*, Published
by: Casemate Publishers, UK. Written by Rupert Wieloch, Year of Publishing: 2019. Subject Area:
Russian History, Civil War, Book Type: History. Total Number
of Pages: 258. ISBN: 9781612007533, $32.95 (Hardcover).
Åslund’s book Russia’s Crony Capitalism: The Path from Market
Economy to Kleptocracy is an interesting book for
anyone who is interested in history of Russian market economy and the state structure.
The book is composed of nine chapters. The first chapter “The
Origins of Putin’s Economic Model” provides a brief description of the
political system, a short historiography of Russian political thought, and its
dominant features throughout the history: conservatism, unrestrained
centralized authority, and nationalism. Then the author then examines the pros
and cons of the socialist economy, the birth of Russian state capitalism, and
crony capitalism. He describes the current economic situation as stable and
stagnant.
The second chapter, “Putin’s Consolidation of Power” depicts
how he consolidated his political power and established his control over the
state apparatus by relying on trusted friends from St, Petersburg, how he built
his “power vertical”, restored federal control over Russia’s various regions,
established his “dictatorship of law” over the judicial system, and how he subordinated
both the executive and judicial powers. The author also describes how Putin and his close associates gained massive amounts of
personal wealth, transforming Russia into a kleptocracy.
In chapter three, “Conservative Fiscal and Monetary
Policy”, the author examines Russia’s conservative macroeconomic policies and economic
problems, and the fundamental causes of the financial crash etc.
Chapter four, “The Rise of State Capitalism”, discusses how
Putin built state capitalism, how his regime confiscated large enterprises such
as Gazprom, Rosneft etc., and why he has allowed only
his close associates to run these corrupt companies. The author states that the
Russian model of crony capitalism is based on an ancient patrimonial model created
deliberately to offer maximum freedom to the ruler. In this ancient system
state collaborations have transformed public property into tsarist ownership.
In chapter five, “The Expansion of Crony Capitalism”, the
author provides detailed information on the new oligarchs, analyses Putin’s
four most important cronies and their businesses, and their place within the
new crony capitalism. The author argues that characterizing Russia under Putin
as an oligarchy is inaccurate since wealth determines the balance of power
among different forces in an oligarchy. Such a balance of power is absent in
Russia today; all power is concentrated in Putin’s hands. Wealth seems to be
more concentrated with a concurrent reduction in transparency. In conclusion
the author provides a quick review of the destinies of the old oligarchs of the
1990s.
In chapter six, “How Large is Russian Wealth, and Why is
it Held Offshore?”, the author, in addition to giving information of the wealth
of Putin’s friends and Putin himself, examines the role of the fourth group, his
lesser-known friends and their wealth which is stored for him in the
Anglo-American offshore. He claims that around $800 billion is held anonymously
abroad, and Putin and cronies have taken over half of it.
Chapter seven, “From International Economic Integration
to Deglobalization”, discusses how Russia’s foreign
economic policy changed after the imposition of Western sanctions on Russia following
Russian aggression against Ukraine in 2014 which resulted in clear division in
Russia between ‘us’ and ‘them’. The author claims that this policy is an odd
combination of increasing trade protectionism and remarkably liberal capital
flows, and its goals have shifted from increased international integration to
isolation and protectionism.
In chapter eight, “Liberalism versus Statism,
or Reform versus Corruption?”, the economic debate
between the two big ideological camps, classical liberals versus statists and
nationalists is examined. The author claims that economists shy away from
discussing the real sources of economic trouble, weak property rights and
corruption, making official economic pronouncements clichéd and colorless. The
consensus among statists and liberals is that only democratization can create the
conditions necessary to solve these problems, and that
official economists are primarily interested in demonstrating their loyalty to
Putin, putting them out of touch with the people’s concerns.
In Chapter nine, which includes conclusion, “Where is Russia
Going, and What Should the West Do?”, the author
assesses the current state of the Russian economy, provides an outlook on
economic policy, and prioritizes the economic reforms Russia should carry out
if genuine economic reform ever becomes a possibility.
Åslund stated that his main aim in this book was to establish the
type of regime Putin has built, where it is going, how it is likely to act, and
how the West can influence it. He has done his research satisfactorily, addressed
the main concerns on Russian political and economical life and given
a clear overview of Russia’s crony capitalism. The book serves its purpose well in that it allows researchers to fill in the gaps in their knowledge on this
specific topic.
*Ayse Dietrich - Professor, Part-time, at Middle East Technical University, Department of History, and Eurasian Studies. Editor and the founder of the International Journal of Russian Studies e-mail: editor@ijors.net, dayse@metu.edu.tr, dietrichayse@yahoo.com
© 2010, IJORS - INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF RUSSIAN STUDIES